Pangea vs Repashy? What Is The Best Crested Gecko Food

Pangea vs Repashy

Normally, owners choose to feed their Crested gecko commercial food as a staple diet. Although, there are a few popular brands, you want the best for your gecko. To help you establish what’s the best commercial diet for your Crested gecko, we are analysing Pangea vs Repashy. Both are composed of similar nutrients but tend to have a different effect on growth rates.

Your Crested gecko’s diet is essential for their development and keeping them healthy throughout their life. Commercial diet is not only the easiest option but also it provides your gecko with all the nutrients, vitamins and minerals they need to stay healthy.

The two heavily researched and tested formulas Repashy Crested Gecko Diet and Pangea Fruit Mix Complete Gecko Diet is what we recommend for your Crested gecko.

This article will help you decide between Pangea vs Repashy by comparing nutrition, cost and overall value.

Pangea Overview

Pangea vs Repashy

According to Pangea’s website:

“Pangea offers one of the most diverse and most trusted Gecko Powder Diets around. Scientifically hand crafted food is made specifically for different stages of a geckos life and even different flavors for picky reptiles. “

The Pangea Fruit Mix Crested Gecko Food is made of over 60% real fruits, no seeds, nuts, or seed meals, cereal grains, high oxalate fruits or vegetables. In addition, the protein is from Whey isolate and egg whites.

There are many flavours to choose from such as Pangea Fruit Mix Watermelon, Pangea Fruit Mix Apricot, Pangea Fruit Mix With Insects, Pangea Fruit Mix Papaya.

Guaranteed analysis for the Pangea Fruit Mix include Crude Protein Min 22%, Crude Fat Min 5%, Crude Fiber Max 8%, Moisture Max 6%, Ash Max 8%

Pangea Fruit Mix have been developed and tested over 5 years to achieve ideal balance of calcium, high quality protein, as well as other nutrients to keep your geckos healthy. In addition, the formula includes biotin which helps avoid deficiency.

Pangea Fruit Mix is meant to be used as a staple diet alongside insect feedings once or twice a week. On the other hand, if you use Pangea Fruit Mix With Insects you won’t have to feed your gecko insects as it’s already included in the formula.

If you want to learn more what insects you can feed to your Crested gecko safely, continue reading here Can Crested Geckos Eat Waxworms? Pro’s And Con’s

Repashy Overview

Pangea vs Repashy

Repashy was the first company to create a commercial Crested gecko diet. Most Crested gecko owners were using the Repashy Crested Gecko during the 2000s. As of 2017, Repashy has to offer 5 formulas with various flavors such as banana, strawberry and mango. The Repashy consistency is like a thick fruity milkshake or smoothie.

The newer Repashy formulas include ingredients such as insect meal, whey, and egg proteins. This blend has proven to keep your gecko healthy during their lifespan of up to 20 years.

The Repashy “Classic” Gecko Diet guaranteed analysis includes: Crude Protein min. 20%, Crude Fat min. 4.5%, Crude Fiber max. 6%, Moisture max. 8%, Ash max. 8%, Calcium min. 1.2%.

One of the conclusions from the 2016 on Comparison of commercial gecko food on growth is that Crested geckos that were fed Pangea and Repashy have had the most significant weight increase compared to other brands.

Although, Pangea and Repashy seem to be the top two brands for gecko commercial food, we want only the best of the best for our Crested gecko. Therefore, which brand is number one – Pangea vs Repashy?

Pangea vs Repashy Comparison

When comparing Pangea vs Repashy, we will be looking at the following factors:

  • Nutrients
  • Aroma, flavor and color
  • Growth
  • Shelf life
  • Cost
  • Bag size

Nutrients

Pangea vs Repashy

To properly compare Pangea vs Repashy, we are using the table below analysing the key components such as protein, fat and fiber.

 Pangea with insectsRepashy Crested Gecko Diet
Protein (min)21%20%
Fat (min)3.5%5%
Fiber (max)8%10%

Pangea contains a minimum of 21% crude proteins, 3.5% crude fat, 8% crude fiber. Whereas, Repashy contains 20% crude proteins, 5% crude fat, 10% crude fiber. The first protein listed on each label is a whey protein label isolate.

Repashy is a meal replacement powder that consists of dried banana, whey protein isolate, dried date, dried fig, etc. On the other hand, Pangea similarly is made of 60% real fruit and whey isolate.

The 2016 on Comparison of commercial gecko food on growth concludes that Pangea is one of the best foods to maintain a healthy Crested gecko. Although, Repashy has similar nutrients to Pangea, the difference is that Pangea also have an insect protein as part of the ingredients.

Aroma, Flavor And Color

When comparing Pangea vs Repashy in terms of aroma, flavor and color – Pangea has more flavors to offer than Repashy.

The one that seems to be heavily favoured by Crested geckos is the Pangea watermelon flavor. Pangea not only has fruity aroma but also colors are added to make it more visually attractive for the gecko.

On the other hand, the old classic Repashy doesn’t have fruity aromas and is brown in color.

However, if you want to offer a Repashy option that is more fragrant, the new classic flavor smells like banana runtz candy and is very much enjoyed by the geckos.

The negative is that those flavors also attract fruit flies. After the food being out for 1 to 2 days, the fruit lay eggs and it result in maggots.

It seems that whatever the fruit flies like, the Crested geckos will also like. Therefore, you will need to compromise in that department.

Overall, in terms of flavor each gecko has different preferences. The only way to find out is to order some testers and see what your Crested gecko likes the most.

Growth

Pangea vs Repashy

When comparing Pangea vs Repashy in terms of gecko growth, both foods provide similar results with Pangea providing steadier weight gain.

As long as the Crested gecko is started on Repashy early, it should produce the same growth results as Pangea.

However, the study from 2016 on Comparison of commercial gecko food on growth by of Dr. Eileen Underwood and Dr. MaryJon Ludy concludes that Pangea provides the best growth rate for the lowest food cost.

Shelf Life

When comparing Pangea vs Repashy in terms of their shelf life, it’s reported that Repashy molds quicker than Pangea.

Not only that, but Pangea is the only brand from the two that provides the information on how long the food will stay fresh in various environments. Pangea’s mix is supposed to be good for 6 months at room temperature and 1 year refrigerated. Whereas, unopened the shelf life is around 2 years.

This information is essential to know how much should be bought at once.

Cost

In the Pangea vs Repashy comparison, cost is an important factor. As bulk packaging is cheaper, we start off with that. Pangea costs $217.99 for 10lb, whereas Repashy costs $95.99 for 4.4lb.

On the other hand, Pangea costs $34.99 for 1lb, whereas Repashy costs $24.99 for 0.75lb.

The conclusion is that Repashy is slightly cheaper compared to Pangea.

Bag Size

When comparing Pangea vs Repashy, we also need to look at what bag sizes each brand offers.

Pangea comes in 2oz (1/8 lb), 8oz (1/2 lb), 16oz (1lb), 64oz (4lb), 10lb (bulk)

Repashy comes in 3oz (0.18lb), 6oz (0.375lb), 12oz (0.75lb), 70.4oz (4.4lb)

Crested Gecko Owners Feedback – Pangea vs Repashy

The most popular commercial food brands that Crested gecko owners recommend are Repashy and Pangea. But which brand has better feedback from Crested gecko’s owners?

After doing some extensive forum research, we’ve found the following results.

According to owners, Repashy has better nutritional value but it doesn’t mix that well as it’s quite bitty. Furthermore, around 2014 Repashy changed their formula and many geckos have gone off it leaving owners to turn to alternatives.

Pangea mixes better and have more flavors to choose from. Furthermore, it’s reported that Crested geckos gain weight at a steadier pace with Pangea compared to Repashy.

For reference, the cost for Repashy 340gr/12oz is $24.99, whereas Pangea 16oz costs $34.99.

Pangea vs RepashyPositivesNegatives
RepashyBetter fat and fiber content
Cheaper
Good option for geckos that are underweight
Doesn’t mix as well
Owners report that their geckos don’t like the new formula
PangeaMixes better than Repashy
Have more flavors to offer
Owners report their geckos gain weight at a steadier pace  
Slightly more expensive than Repashy

Final Thoughts

In this article, we compared Pangea vs Repashy in terms of nutritional value, cost, flavors and owners feedback.

The conclusion is that when comparing Pangea vs Repashy – Pangea produces good and steady growth rate, tend to mold at a slower pace, have good consistency and more flavors to choose from.

Our recommendation is the Pangea Fruit Mix Complete Gecko Diet and is supported by owners first hand experience and supported by the 2016 on Comparison of commercial gecko food on growth.

Related Topics Q&A

How To Mix/Prepare Pangea?

Directions: Feed Pangea Gecko diet daily. Mix 1 part powder to 2 parts water, adjust to achieve desired consistency. Prepared mix is good for up to 7 days if refrigerated.

Open dry mix is good for 6 months at room temperature or 1 year if refrigerated.

How To Mix/Prepare Repashy?

Directions: Mix one part MRP with two parts water by volume as a starting point. The mixture may appear watery at first, but will thicken after several minutes.

If separation occurs over time, use less water. As fed, MRP should have the consistency of ketchup.

Feed geckos in the evening and remove uneaten MRP within 24 hours.

You may also like...